|
GRADING CRITERIA:
Presentation: length of speaking time,
enthusiasm, does presenter expand on the information written on their slides?
Does presenter know what he/she is talking about?
Technical Description: Is the information
presented in such a way that anyone would understand? Did presenter use
illustrations, demonstrations, graphs, visual aide to explain technology?
Ethical Issues: There are four
aspects—professional, legal, and ethical issues, as well as the stakeholders.
Two points taken off for each missing issue.
Ethical Analysis: There are seven possible views
to address—utilitarian, rights, fairness/justice, common good, virtues,
Kantian.
One point taken off for each missing view.
If possible actions not addressed, one additional point taken off.
Conclusion: Is it decisive and does it logically
follow from the issues and analysis?
|